I’ve never had much of a problem forming an opinion, but for some Red I have yet to make up my mind about the Valentino Aphrodite Satchel. Is it great, or is it ever-so-slightly off? Do all of the elements work together, or does it look like two disparate bags joined into one?

After the jump, I’ve listed the design’s pros and cons and also provided a convenient poll for your voting pleasure.

Valentino high-waisted cut-out detail skirt

Pros:

1. Color and pattern: Lovely! The origin of the print is somewhat indeterminate (although it’s clearly some sort of cat), but the cream and black combination makes the overall effect a bit more ladylike than leopard. For the shape and design of this bag, it was the perfect choice.
2. Scale: The size of the pattern relative to the size of the bag is bold and graphic, just as modern animal print should be.
3. Shape: “Lady scale” bags are the new ish, apparently, and this bag fits fall’s 60s trends perfectly.
4. The Bow: It adds an unexpected twist to the bag and makes the design distinctively Valentino.

Cons:

1. The Bow: Is it a pro or a con? I can’t decide. This entire poll is really just a referendum on the bow. The color doesn’t appear elsewhere in the design, which is what gives me pause. Does the bow throw you off as well, or does the contrast add something?

[poll id=”63″]

Valentino Garavani Rockstud detail ankle booties.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

52 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
An4
An4
13 years ago

maybe you should see it in person?

the contrast doesn’t work for me, I’d like to see the bow in the color of the trim. or black.

covertanjou
covertanjou
13 years ago

Without the bow, the bag would be beautiful. With the bow, the bag just does not work for me.

pauline
pauline
13 years ago

If the bow were black, this bag would be great. The color is just wrong against the print

Laura
Laura
13 years ago

The color of the bow isn’t working, I think black would make it the perfect bag.

Amy Beth
Amy Beth
13 years ago

I love it, with the bow.

T
T
13 years ago

I agree with Amy Beth I love it too! I like the fact that they decided not to go with the typical black bow and chose the tan. It gives you many more options when deciding what shoes to wear. With the whole Mad Man craze it fits in purrfectly!

T
T
13 years ago

Oops I think it’s Mad Men? Mad man is a state of being!

Claire
Claire
13 years ago

Handbag VALENTINO Tandoori VBS6GG03 Orchidea D66!

Brandy
Brandy
13 years ago

Not exactly a big fan of bows to begin with so I hate it. But… it could work if it was black. Or even that taupe color that the rest of the bag is. The tan color just doesn’t fit. But if it was my choice I would at least size it down or get rid of it all together. The print is fantastic though

Purse Pixie
Purse Pixie
13 years ago

The pattern of the bag is beautiful but I agree that the bow doesn’t work in that color. I think black would make it boring but maybe a darker brown?

Trending