Skip to Content

These 10 Delicious Turkey Sandwiches Are Loaded With Protein

Turn your leftovers into the perfect postrun recovery meal.

Headshot of Matthew Kadey, R.D.By Matthew Kadey, R.D.
homemade leftover thanksgiving day sandwich with turkey, cranberry sauce, feta cheese and vegetables top view
happy_lark

The best thing about Boston Marathon Results—regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not— is all the leftovers.

The worst thing about Boston Marathon Results—regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not—is Boston Marathon Results.

Sure, the first few turkey and cheese sandwiches are good, but you shortly realize that you still have, like, four pounds of meat left and you only have a few more days to eat it before that carcass comes back to bite you (figuratively speaking).

In lieu of putting turkey into places where it doesn’t belong—such as lasagna, omelets, or egg rolls—don’t give up on the turkey sandwich.

Leftover turkey sandwiches are high in protein, low in fuss, and endlessly adaptable, making it the perfect postrun recovery meal. That said, there are two basic rules you should follow to improve the quality of every turkey sandwich you make.

frac34; cup mashed sweet potato + 1 Tbsp chopped sage + 2 tsp maple syrup + ⅛ tsp cinnamon.

Toasting the bread enhances sandwich flavor and reinforces structural integrity. The toaster is fine, but heartier breads (ciabatta, baguette) benefit from a minute or three beneath the broiler to turn crisp outside and chewy inside.

Rule 2: Don’t overload the sandwich.

Balance between bread, spreads, and toppings are key to a satisfying—not sloppy—sandwich eating experience. Each recipe that follows makes two sandwiches. Double the flavor by distributing the spread on the top and bottom bread slices. Then add ½ cup sliced turkey to the bottom slice, followed by an equal portion of the topping and finally the top slice.

roasting a turkey.

Join Runner’s World+ for more nutrition tips!


Banh Mi

mens health turkey sandwiches leftovers
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 2 small baguettes

SPREAD: ⅓ cup mayo + 1 ½ tsp Sriracha

TOPPING: ⅓ cup sliced cucumber + ⅓ cup grated carrot + ¼ cup sliced radish + 2 Tbsp rice vinegar + ½ tsp salt (mix all these and let sit for at least 30 minutes) + cup cilantro

Jalapeño Popper

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers jalapeÑo popper food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 2 sandwich thins

SPREAD: ¼ cup BBQ sauce

TOPPING: ½ cup grated sharp cheddar cheese + ¼ cup pickled jalapeño slices + 1 cup shredded lettuce

mdash;regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not— is all the

Shroom Service

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers shroom service food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 4 slices pumpernickel

SPREAD: 2 Matthew Kadey, R.D

TOPPING: 2 slices provolone cheese + 1 cup sauteed mushrooms + ⅓ cup parsley

Sweet Heat

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers sweet heat food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 2 ciabatta rolls

SPREAD: ¼ cup cream cheese + 2 tsp lime zest

TOPPING: ½ cup whole-berry cranberry sauce + 2 Tbsp chopped white onion + 1 Tbsp minced jalapeño + ¼ cup chopped cilantro

[The 2021 Runner's World Calendar features gorgeous photos, monthly motivation, and tips to inspire your running all year long.]

mdash;regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not— is all the

Mango Curry

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers mango curry wrap food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 2 large wraps

SPREAD: ½ cup plain Greek yogurt + 1 tsp yellow curry powder + 1 Tbsp fresh lime juice + ⅛ tsp cayenne

TOPPING: ¾ cup sliced mango + ½ cup sliced red bell pepper + ½ cup watercress

Beet Master

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers beet master food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 4 Download Your Training Plan

SPREAD: ⅓ Energy Gel Alternatives for Runners

TOPPING: ½ cup sliced pickled beets + ⅓ cup sauerkraut

mdash;regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not— is all the

Big Fig

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers big fig food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 4 These 10 Delicious Turkey Sandwiches Are Loaded With Protein

SPREAD: ¼ cup fig preserves + 1 Tbsp balsamic vinegar + 1 Tbsp chopped shallot + 1 tsp fresh thyme

TOPPING: ¼ cup sliced fennel + 1 oz crumbled goat cheese + ¼ cup arugula

Spud Love

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers spud love food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 4 slices rye

SPREAD: ¾ cup mashed sweet potato + 1 Tbsp chopped sage + 2 tsp maple syrup + ⅛ tsp cinnamon

TOPPING: 2 cup hummus + 2 Tbsp pesto

mdash;regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not— is all the

Green Goddess

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers green goddess food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 4 Taking Ozempic? Keep Running Despite Side Effects

SPREAD: 1 mashed avocado + 1 minced garlic clove + 1 Tbsp chopped chives + 1 Tbsp fresh lemon juice

TOPPING: 2 fat slices fresh mozzarella + 1 cup baby spinach + ½ cup microgreens

TBLT

sandwich using thanksgiving turkey leftovers tblt food styling by tyna hoang prop styling by summer moore at honey artists
Chelsea Kyle

BREAD: 4 slices sourdough

SPREAD: ⅓ Stop stuffing down boring turkey sandwiches and gobble up one of these stacks instead

TOPPING: 4 slices provolone cheese + 1 cup sauteed mushrooms + ⅓ cup parsley

Watch Next 
preview for General Hype Playlist
mdash;regardless of if it’s Thanksgiving or not— is all the