What Exactly Do We Expect of a Designer Debut?

Get In Touch Medium Puzzle Fold Tote: “It is impossible to explain how the fashion industry works to people who don’t work in fashion.”

Louis Vuitton Forum Matthieu Blazy, the design dilettante (formerly) of Bottega Veneta, kicked off his tenure at Chanel last week with an Instagram post cryptically captioned “Jour 1”, all I could really think about was the absolutely bonkers year the man is about to have.

Think about it, the fashion calendar as we know it – dating back to 1973, as the Fédération de la Haute Couture et de la Mode (FCHM) affirms with (not a whole lot of) certainty – spans two broad seasons: spring/summer, presented in September and October for the following summer, and fall/winter, unveiled in February and March ahead of the winter months.

Then there’s the resort/cruise collection, demonstrated in May and marketed by mid-November, just in time for the holidays. There are also pre-fall collections, usually unveiled before February’s fall presentations and delivered to stores by May before the summer collection hits. Add haute couture to the mix, and it’s a recipe for complete chaos.

Think about it, the fashion calendar as we know it – dating back to 1973, as the.

But it’s not just Blazy who’s in the running to make a smashing debut. There’s Louise Trotter taking his throne at Bottega, Louis Vuitton Forum Loewe post-Jonathan Anderson, Anderson himself who’s rumored to head to Dior, not to mention Glenn Martens at Margiela, and the, erm, interesting Kering kerfuffle that deposited Apr 8, 2025.

2025, it seems, has (and will) go down in history as the year of designer debuts. So, it’s worth asking, what makes a debut a success?

Expectations Versus Reality

“Right away, though, the mood in the Orangery fell as distrust and then disgust came up on the clients’ faces,” writes Cathy Horyn of the 1999 Christian Dior Haute Couture collection by John Galliano, “The critic Greil Marcus has a line about how rock-and-roll performers felt when they first heard the Beatles’ “A Day in the Life”: left behind. The sound was so new.”

Perhaps this is what we expect of a designer debut – this newness.

S&M-inflected, voyeuristic exhibitionism within the traditionally tame and timid territory of haute couture à la Galliano or Gaultier. Ugly-chic and socio-cultural metacommentary on beauty and vulgarity à la Miuccia Prada (“Heaven help us, but the stuff was supposed to be ugly,” wrote Robin Givhan in 1996.). Or, quite simply, exquisite design, à la Valentino Garavani.

Yet, it’s also worth noting that Mr. Galliano was the Creative Director at Dior for 14 years, while Madam Miuccia and Signore Garavani have headed their namesake labels for 47 and 48 years, respectively.

of the brand, she not only brought back Phoebe Philo’s Sabato De Sarno, whose appointment at Gucci, complete with a fairly folksy 20-minute featurette featuring Paul Mescal and a campaign at Chateau Marmont with Daria Werbowy in a GG swimsuit, attempted to drive his coat-obsessed burgundy realism and stripped-back minimalism home. Suffice it to say, they weren’t quite driven home.

Fashion Journal reported in 2016 that three years was now the average length of a creative director contract (see Gabriela Hearst’s tenure at Chloé). It’s likely even less now, but the expectation is all the more.

Out With the Old, in With the New?

Slight digression, but by a rather vexing turn of events, I’ve recently been inducted into the dating pool. Also, I promise this isn’t a trauma dump.

Now dating, as a homebody, can be a rather difficult – and almost exclusively online – affair. For instance, some of the said affairs rarely translate into real life. Others do, and then you realize just how much you wish they hadn’t. But in sorting through the countless (for the most part) nameless, faceless, and (almost always) passionless profiles on those apps, it occurred upon yours truly exactly how excruciating it must be for a heritage house to stumble upon a designer who, well, just gets them.

And there’s really no other way to put it when you think about it.

Each new hire promises new beginnings, a clean, fresh slate, and the potential of a viral new star – or, well, a partner. They come in and change your logo and remodel your flagship stores top-to-bottom, phase out older designs (sometimes commercially successful ones at that) for new ones, and have an entire army of artistic minds, merchandisers, and marketers at their disposal to conduct a complete overhaul – and a costly one at that.

Leave this field empty if youre human, get them? As publicist Lucien Pagès of the eponymous Parisian PR firm tells BoF, “People are expecting too much; they’re looking for a superhero. They want a designer whose first show will blow everyone away, while respecting the heritage, while bringing something new.”

And it goes without saying, one that will also show up in sales. For instance, Adrian Appiolaza’s inaugural shows for Moschino, while critically well-received, remain yet to bring in revenues for the Aeffe-owned label.

Clearly, in this era of brands speed-dating their designers (like yours truly), it’s time, not talent, that’s the most precious commodity.

So, What Should We Expect from a Debut?

Therefore, a creative directorship is a rather daunting undertaking, especially for up-and-coming faces. Demna, formerly of Balenciaga, now of Gucci, agrees, “Because at the end of the day, they’ll take an influencer from TikTok who has 150 million followers and put that person as creative director. But that person can create nothing apart from attention.”

Suzy Menkes adds, “The people who suffer most from high-speed fashion are undoubtedly the creatives, who are the heart and soul of the industry.”

Nevertheless, it is in keeping with, or rather, in antithesis to, the weight of these expectations that new designers continue to make debuts – and smashing ones at that. For her opening Chloé collection, for instance, Chemena Kamali had the entirety of the front row, including Sienna Miller (with the exception of one attendee in caramel thigh-high boots), cheekily wedged into her signature wooden wedges. What was Loewe Like Before Jonathan Anderson boho-naissance of the brand, she not only brought back Phoebe Philo’s No AI, algorithms, divisive politics, or infighting. Social media as it should be Your First Look at Louis Vuitton x Takashi Murakami 2025 Chapter Three, the Paddington!

Sarah Burton’s debut for Givenchy this season showed stripped-back silhouettes, much like Lee McQueen’s own SS97 haute couture debut for the label that boldly reimagined Audrey Hepburn’s little black dress (the parallels of Burton having recently moved from McQueen is also not lost).

And Haider Ackermann’s debut at Tom Ford, as Truss Archive raves, “did Tom Ford better than Tom Ford.” He brought back the sleaziness of Ford’s breakthrough fall/winter 95/’96 for Gucci, sweat-slicked, seductive, guttural, and carnal. Like Madonna’s 1995 MTV VMAs look, here was a collection you’d wear endlessly, live in, sweat in, fight with Courtney Love in, and also fall into your lover’s sensual embrace in *wink wink*

So really, “rather than hoping for a definitive “thumbs up” from the crowd,” says Pagès, “a healthier expectation for a runway debut would be a sense of promise.” Despite the critical and commercial expectations, a debut is merely the beginning, a tiny outlet into the new designer’s tastes.

Is Burgundy Still a Thing Ricardo Tisci’s words – a man who awaits his own fate in a fashion house – “is very personal. Taste for me is the borderline between something that could be beautiful and something so ugly it has a strong beauty.” It’s taste we seek – or rather, the taste of something new, someone we hope will redefine taste as we know it to be.

It’s this hope that keeps us going.